Teaching Kids About Legal Precedence
An American Civics lesson from Intellect Inbox
The following is a lesson generated by an early version of Intellect Inbox: an AI service helping parents guide their child’s education. Want free lessons like this straight to your inbox every day? Join our waitlist at www.mumma.co/intellectinbox
Hello, Ben!
Introduction to the Topic
Today, we're exploring the concept of Precedent in Supreme Court Decision Making. This is an essential principle within the American legal system, specifically in how the Supreme Court and other courts view and make decisions on legal cases. Understanding this concept can offer profound insights into how law evolves in the United States and impacts its citizens.
Core Concepts
What is Precedent? Precedent, in the context of law, refers to an earlier court decision or ruling that is considered as an example or guide to be considered in subsequent similar cases. The term comes from the Latin 'praecedens' which literally means 'going before'. In legal terms, it's the foundation of the doctrine known as stare decisis, which means "to stand by things decided."
Stare Decisis This principle compels courts to follow legal precedents set by previous decisions when ruling on a case with similar circumstances. Its two main purposes are to maintain legal consistency over time, thereby providing predictability, and to ensure fair and impartial justice.
Types of Precedents
Binding Precedent: Decisions from higher courts are binding on lower courts within the same jurisdiction.
Persuasive Precedent: Decisions from an outside jurisdiction that are not obligatory but can influence or guide decisions in a new case.
Role of the Supreme Court The Supreme Court is at the top of the federal court system in the United States. It has the ultimate authority to interpret the Constitution and sets binding precedents for all other courts in the country. However, it can also overturn its previous decisions, though this is relatively rare, reflecting its adaptability to changing values and norms within society.
Engaging Kids with the Topic
Discussion Starter: Kick off with a simple question: "Why do you think rules are important?" Lead this into a discussion on how laws are like the rules for a country, and the Supreme Court helps interpret those rules.
Interactive Media: There are numerous educational videos online that animate complex court cases or decisions, making them more accessible and engaging. Watching these together can open the door to discussion about specific precedents and their outcomes.
Role-Play: Create a mock courtroom scenario at home. Assign roles (judge, lawyers, jury) and work through a simplified historical case. After the verdict, discuss how this case could serve as a precedent for future cases.
Ideas for Assignments, Projects, or Experiments
Research Project: Choose a significant Supreme Court case. Have your child research the case to understand its background, the decision made, and its impact on laws and society. They can present their findings through a poster, presentation, or even a short video.
Creative Writing: Encourage your child to write a short story or play that revolves around a fictional court case. This will require them to think about the concept of precedent and how a decision could impact future cases.
Debate Club: Host a family debate night on a contentious issue, such as the use of technology in classrooms. Begin by presenting a hypothetical Supreme Court decision on the matter, and then debate its merits. This encourages critical thinking and understanding the importance of precedent in legal decisions.
Field Trip: If possible, visit your local courthouse to observe a trial in session, or take a trip to a legal museum. Many courts offer educational programs or tours that can provide a more tangible understanding of the justice system.
By engaging with the concept of precedent in these interactive and creative ways, your child will gain a deeper understanding of the American legal system and how Supreme Court decisions influence the country's laws and its citizens' lives. Remember, the goal is to spark curiosity and encourage critical thinking, so any activity should be adaptable to best suit your child's interests and learning style. Happy learning, Ben!
